Personal Finance

Two Jobs, One Tax-Free Threshold: Why the Second Payslip Looks Over-Taxed

Two jobs? Claim the tax-free threshold on the higher-paying one. At 2026-27 rates the second job is often under-withheld, so check for a bill before June.

Published

on

The second payslip arrives, and something about it looks wrong. You worked the same kind of hours you work at your main job, maybe a few Saturday shifts or an evening run of Christmas casual work, and yet a bigger slice has gone to tax than you expected. You might be wondering whether you filled in the form wrong, whether second jobs are taxed at some special higher rate, or whether you should just tick the tax-free threshold box on this one too and make the problem go away. Here is the short answer. Claim the tax-free threshold from the job that pays you the most, which is what the Australian Taxation Office recommends. Then judge the second payslip against your main income, not against your first payslip. At 2026-27 rates, if your main job pays more than about $45,000 a year, the usual end result is a small bill at tax time, not a refund. The quick check below tells you where to claim the threshold, which part of this article to read for your situation, and the step to take this week.

Where should I claim the tax-free threshold?

Answer a few quick questions. You get where to claim the threshold, the part of this article to read next, and the step to take this week.

If this helper does not load: claim the tax-free threshold with your higher-paying job only, leave it unticked on the other, then use "What to do this week" to choose between extra withholding on the second job and setting money aside.

Do you have more than one job right now?

Count every employer that pays you a wage, including casual and seasonal work.

Is one job clearly your higher-paying one?

Think about the whole year, not a single payslip. Skip this if you have one job.

Have you already claimed the threshold on more than one job?

Your payslip or the TFN declaration you gave each employer shows whether you claimed it.

Would you rather avoid a bill at tax time?

The other way is to keep more of each pay now and set money aside yourself.

Has a payslip or the ATO shown less tax withheld than you expected?

This includes a bill or notice after you lodge.

Answer the questions and your summary will appear here.

This helper only uses your answers. It does not work out your tax or any amount.

General information, not tax advice. The ATO decides what you owe.

What the threshold is, and why only one payer gets it

The tax-free threshold is the first $18,200 of income an Australian resident earns in a financial year, and no income tax is charged on it. Spread across a year, that is $350 a week. When you tell an employer on your tax file number declaration that you are claiming the threshold, the ATO says that payer withholds nothing from pay below $363 a week, and less tax on everything above it.

The catch is that there is only one $18,200 to go around, however many jobs you hold. The ATO’s guidance is that you generally claim it from one payer, usually the one that pays the highest salary or wage. If you are a resident for only part of the year, your threshold is pro-rated, and non-residents cannot claim it at all.

So if you claimed it on your main job and left the box unticked on the second, you did the right thing. Nothing went wrong on the form.

Why the second payslip looks heavier

Your second employer has no idea what your main job pays. It only knows you have not claimed the threshold with it, so it withholds tax from the very first dollar you earn there, using what the ATO calls the no-tax-free-threshold scale. That is the whole reason the payslip looks heavier. The second job is not taxed at a different or higher rate. Tax is assessed on your combined income when you lodge your return, and the withholding along the way is only an estimate of that.

The table puts numbers on it. The figures come from the ATO’s 2026-27 Schedule 1 withholding formulas, published on 17 June 2026, for the same weekly pay on each scale.

Weekly pay Withheld, threshold not claimed (second job) Withheld, threshold claimed (main job)
$300 $52 $0
$400 $72 $6
$500 $90 $21
$800 $184 $83

Seeing $72 come out of a $400 week when the same pay at your main job would lose $6 is a jolt, and it is fair to feel it. A smaller payslip every week is a real cost to your household, even if the year balances out in the end. Rent, groceries and petrol do not wait for July. If that is the part that hurts, you are not imagining it. People working two jobs raise this point often, and it is a fair one: the year may balance, but the week does not.

Still, the week and the year are two different questions. The rest of this piece is about the year.

Which way it evens out

Most of what you will read about second jobs says it all evens out at tax time. That is true, as far as it goes. What it rarely says is which way it evens out, and that depends almost entirely on what your main job pays.

The 2026-27 resident tax rates, from the ATO, are:

  • $0 to $18,200: nil
  • $18,201 to $45,000: 15 cents for each dollar over $18,200
  • $45,001 to $135,000: $4,020 plus 30 cents for each dollar over $45,000
  • $135,001 to $190,000: $31,020 plus 37 cents for each dollar over $135,000
  • $190,001 and over: $51,370 plus 45 cents for each dollar over $190,000

On top of those sits the 2% Medicare levy for most people. One small ruling while we are here: some well-ranked pages still quote 19% and 32.5% brackets. Those rates are several years out of date. For 2026-27 the two brackets most workers fall into are 15% and 30%, according to the ATO, and the 15% rate itself came down from 16% in 2025-26.

Now look back at the table. At $300 to $500 a week, the no-threshold scale takes roughly 17 to 18 cents in every dollar. That rate quietly assumes your other income sits somewhere near the bottom brackets. If your main job pays more than about $45,000, every extra dollar you earn on top of it lands in the 30% bracket, and with the Medicare levy that is 32 cents in the dollar. If you want to see how that top rate works on your own income, our explainer on salary sacrifice into super walks through what your marginal rate means for each extra dollar.

So 17 or 18 cents set aside against a 32-cent tax falls short by roughly 14 cents in every dollar of second-job pay. Over a summer of shifts, that gap builds into a bill.

Below about $45,000 from the main job, the picture tends to flip. Your extra dollars are taxed at 15 cents plus the levy, the low income tax offset helps further, and the second job’s withholding usually collects about enough or a little more. That is the refund most people have in mind when they say it all comes back. The ATO’s own examples go both ways for exactly this reason: in one, a person with two modest incomes gets a refund; in another, someone with two incomes adding up to $60,000 ends the year owing money.

I am not going to tell you which side of the line you sit on from a paragraph, because it depends on your pay, your weeks and everything else in your tax affairs. The quick check above will point you to the section that fits your situation. What I can do is show you three examples.

Three worked examples

These are hypothetical people, not real cases. Each one uses the ATO’s 2026-27 resident rates and Schedule 1 withholding formulas, and assumes a full-year Australian resident with no study loan, no deductions and no other income. Every result is rounded, so read each one as “about”.

Example A: the Christmas casual

Say a worker earns $1,000 a week at her main job all year and claims the tax-free threshold there. In November she picks up a casual retail role at $400 a week for 10 weeks, and leaves the threshold box unticked, as she should.

  • Withheld by the main job: $138 a week for 52 weeks, about $7,176
  • Withheld by the casual job: $72 a week for 10 weeks, about $720
  • Total withheld: about $7,896
  • Combined income: $56,000
  • Tax on $56,000, less the low income tax offset, plus the Medicare levy: about $8,280

Result: a bill of about $384. That works out to about $38 for each week of casual work that was under-withheld. It is a manageable sum, though it is not the refund she may have been counting on.

Example A again: threshold claimed on both jobs

Now say she ticked the threshold box on the casual job as well, on the thinking that it would help her week-to-week income. The casual job now withholds just $6 a week, about $60 for the 10 weeks. Her tax on $56,000 does not change at all.

Result: a bill of about $1,044. The double claim added about $660 to what she owes. The bigger casual payslips were really an advance on her own tax bill.

Example B: the student

Say a student earns $350 a week at a part-time job all year, with the threshold claimed there. Over the summer he adds a casual job at $300 a week for 8 weeks.

  • Withheld by the main job: $0
  • Withheld by the casual job: $52 a week for 8 weeks, about $416
  • Combined income: $20,600
  • Tax on $20,600 is about $360, and the $700 low income tax offset wipes it out completely
  • No Medicare levy applies, because his income is below the $28,011 low-income threshold that the ATO’s 2026-27 withholding schedule uses for singles

Result: a refund of about $416. Everything the casual job withheld comes back to him.

Put the two people side by side and the pattern is clear. They follow the same rules and fill in the same forms, and they end up on opposite sides. The only real difference between them is what the main job pays.

What to do this week

If your own numbers point to a bill, you have two straightforward options, and both come from the ATO.

Ask the second employer to withhold extra. You can make a written request for your second payer to take out more tax from each pay, through what the ATO calls a PAYG withholding variation. Your payslip shrinks a little more each week, and the bill at the end of the year shrinks with it, or disappears.

Or set the shortfall aside yourself. If you would rather keep the cash flow, put the gap somewhere safe each pay day, in a separate savings account you leave alone until you lodge. Example A gives a sense of scale: about $38 for each week of casual work. If you like the idea of a calmer tax time generally, our piece on handling taxes without last-minute stress has a few habits that make that money easier to leave alone.

A few situations work differently, so it is worth checking whether one of these is you:

  • Your combined income for the whole year is $18,200 or less. The ATO lets you claim the threshold from each payer in this case. If your income later rises above $18,200, you lodge a withholding declaration with one of them to stop claiming it there.
  • You have changed jobs rather than added one. You can claim the threshold from your new payer.
  • You have a study loan. It adds extra withholding on top of everything here, and it is not included in the examples here.

Whatever applies, the step you can take today is small. Have a look at your latest payslips from both jobs, see which one has the threshold claimed, and run your numbers once.

Settle it on the TFN declaration

Most of the second-job worry comes from comparing one payslip with another, and that comparison was never going to look fair. The second employer is following the rules exactly. It just cannot see the rest of your year.

So keep it simple. One threshold, claimed with one payer, the one that pays you most. Leave it unticked everywhere else, and do not claim it twice, because that only makes the bill bigger. Then, if your main job pays more than about $45,000, assume the second job is running a little short and decide now whether you would rather have extra withheld or put the difference aside. A quick check in March, with a few months of real pay on your payslips, will tell you whether you are on track.

If your situation is more tangled than this, with several jobs, business income, a study loan or a big change partway through the year, it is completely reasonable to hand it to someone who does this every day. Our guide to choosing a tax agent can help you find the right one. Otherwise, you now know which way your year is likely to go, and that is most of the work done.

This article is general information, not tax advice. It describes the ATO’s published rates and withholding formulas for 2026-27.

Sources: Multiple jobs or change of job, Australian Taxation Office (https://www.ato.gov.au/individuals-and-families/jobs-and-employment-types/tax-free-threshold/multiple-jobs-or-change-of-job); Coefficients to use in formulas for withholding from weekly payments, Australian Taxation Office (https://www.ato.gov.au/tax-rates-and-codes/payg-withholding-schedule-1-statement-of-formulas-for-calculating-amounts-to-be-withheld/coefficients-to-use-in-formulas-for-withholding-from-weekly-payments); Tax rates for Australian residents, Australian Taxation Office (https://www.ato.gov.au/tax-rates-and-codes/tax-rates-australian-residents)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending

Exit mobile version