Home & Garden
An Evaporative Cooler Runs Cheaper Than an Air Conditioner Only While the Air Stays Dry
An evaporative cooler uses less electricity than an air conditioner. That part is settled. Whether it costs less to run depends on two things the brochure leaves out: how dry the air is, and what the water costs.
The verdict is conditional, and it stays that way. In dry air, evaporative cooling is the cheaper machine to run, often by a wide margin. In humid air it stops cooling well, and a low power bill buys nothing. The quoted savings of half, a third or three-quarters are not constants. They come out of the watts you use. Type your own watts, hours and rate into the calculator below and the sum is done.
Compare the running cost of your two coolers
Enter the watts for each unit, the hours and days you run them, and the rate from your bill. Add the water use and water price if you want the water counted. The result updates as you type.
Enter both wattages, the hours and days, and the rate from your bill, and the two running costs appear here.
Enter both wattages, the hours, the days and the rate to see the comparison.
The watts are on the plate or label. For the air conditioner, use the average while it runs, not the full-load figure.
The article's table sets out the rates it uses. Your rate is on your bill. This only does the arithmetic.
Uses only the numbers you type. It does not include supply charges, time-of-use periods, solar export, servicing or purchase cost, and it does not know your tariff, your wattage or your water price. Check your bill and the label.
Why the quoted savings run from half to three-quarters
Every source opened says evaporative cooling uses less electricity. None agrees on by how much. Five are set out below, with the baseline each one measures against.
| Source | Claim | Baseline | Date |
|---|---|---|---|
| energy.gov.au | Less than half the electricity | Air conditioner of similar capacity (ducted evaporative) | Undated page |
| RACV | About half the energy | Similarly sized ducted split system | 19 Nov 2024 |
| CHOICE | $200 to $300 a year against $400 to $500 | Medium-sized air conditioner | 27 Jan 2022 |
| Queensland Government | About one-third the energy | Refrigerated air conditioners | 2025 file, no printed date |
| SolarQuotes | Up to 75 per cent less electricity | Reverse cycle systems | 15 Dec 2025 |
These are not five estimates of one number. They are five baselines. Half, one-third and three-quarters can all be correct if the air conditioner each is compared with draws different watts.
CHOICE’s dollar figures work out at roughly half, although its own text calls the running cost “ultimately comparable to air conditioning”. They also come from a page last updated in January 2022, on tariffs from that period. Use its ratio and its watts. Do not read its dollars as today’s prices.
One installer guide opened for this article gives three different percentages on a single page and states no tariff. A percentage with no baseline cannot be checked.
So treat the ratio as an answer, not an input. It falls out of the watts on each side. That is the next sum.
The sum on three tariffs
Take a hypothetical household. The evaporative cooler draws 350 watts at the fan speed in use. That sits inside the 200 to 400 watts CHOICE gives for evaporative units, and SolarQuotes says “a few hundred watts”. The air conditioner averages 1,000 watts while it runs. CHOICE says a medium unit draws up to about 1 kilowatt, so this is a generous figure for the refrigerated side. Both run 8 hours a day for 30 days. These inputs are ours. They are not a market average.
That gives 84 kilowatt hours for the evaporative cooler and 240 for the air conditioner. The rates are the Australian Energy Regulator’s 2026-27 default market offer caps for flat-rate residential tariffs, GST inclusive, in force from 1 July 2026. Your own rate is on your bill.
| Network | Rate per kWh | Evaporative | Air conditioner | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ausgrid | 33.1372 cents | $27.84 | $79.53 | $51.69 |
| Energex | 27.9744 cents | $23.50 | $67.14 | $43.64 |
| SA Power Networks | 41.9103 cents | $35.20 | $100.58 | $65.38 |
The ratio is 65 per cent less on every network. The tariff moves the dollars. Only the watts move the ratio. Per hour on the South Australian cap, that is about 15 cents for the evaporative cooler against about 42 cents for the air conditioner.
The method is the one behind our Christmas lights running cost sum: watts times hours, divided by 1,000, times the rate. The air fryer against the oven comparison runs on the same logic, where the deciding variable is yours to measure. Here it is your wattage.
Now apply each source’s ratio to the South Australian air conditioner bill of $100.58.
| Ratio used | Source | Evaporative bill it implies |
|---|---|---|
| About half | RACV | $50.29 |
| About one-third | Queensland Government | $33.53 |
| 75 per cent less | SolarQuotes | $25.15 |
The sum above gives $35.20, between the first two. None of the three is wrong. Each sits on a different pair of machines. The ratio is an output.
Humidity decides whether the saving exists
A cheap machine that does not cool is not cheap. Humidity decides which one you have bought.
Evaporative cooling works by evaporating water into the air stream. Dry air takes up that water and the temperature falls. Humid air takes up little, and the temperature falls less. The Queensland Government’s guide puts the best conditions at around 30 per cent humidity and the maximum at 50. SolarQuotes gives a worked example: on a 35 degree day at 30 per cent humidity, indoor air comes down to about 23 degrees. At 60 per cent it may only reach about 30. That is twelve degrees of cooling against five. Expect a cooler room, not a cold one: the Queensland Government suggests aiming for 24 to 28 degrees indoors. CHOICE does not recommend evaporative cooling for humid or wet climates, and Your Home says it works best where humidity is low.
Past 50 per cent the cooler is outside its stated range. It still draws its watts. The power ratio is intact and the cooling is not. That is the worst trade on offer.
The guides share one workaround. On humid days, switch the pump off and run the fan only (Queensland Government, SolarQuotes). That uses the fan’s watts and circulates no water.
Three conditions sit outside the sum. First, the air needs somewhere to go. Your Home says some windows or doors must stay open, and the Queensland Government says to open a window at the far end by 25 to 50 millimetres. Second, a portable unit is a different machine. energy.gov.au says portable units recirculate indoor air and can add humidity and warm the room unless air flows outside. Third, smoke. Your Home says to limit use when outside air quality is low, such as during bushfires.
The other side has a fair point. A reverse cycle system copes with humid days, and it heats in winter. An evaporative cooler does neither.
Dry heat, yes. Humid heat, no.
Water is the cost nobody prices
The electricity sum is half the picture. An evaporative cooler uses water, and the guides do not agree on how much.
Your Home gives about 4 litres an hour for a portable unit and 25 or more for a central unit on hot, dry days. energy.gov.au says up to 25, and RACV gives 25. SolarQuotes says 15 or more, and 15 to 30 or more for a four-bedroom system. The Queensland Government says around 75 litres an hour in summer. CHOICE, citing a 2009 study, reports 41 to 70 litres an hour in Hobart and 67 to 116 in Adelaide. The current guides run from 4 to 75, roughly twenty times apart, and SolarQuotes says more than 100 for a large unit in particularly dry conditions.
Price the water with the same method. Take 25 litres an hour, 8 hours a day, 30 days. That is 6,000 litres, or 6 kilolitres. Every dollar of water price per kilolitre adds $6 to the month. At 75 litres an hour it is 18 kilolitres, and every dollar adds $18.
The useful question is where the saving stops. Divide the electricity saving from the sum above by the kilolitres used and you have the break-even water price per kilolitre.
| Network | Saving on power | Break-even at 25 L/h | Break-even at 75 L/h |
|---|---|---|---|
| SA Power Networks | $65.38 | $10.90 | $3.63 |
| Ausgrid | $51.69 | $8.62 | $2.87 |
| Energex | $43.64 | $7.27 | $2.42 |
Those figures are dollars per kilolitre. If your water price is below the figure in your row, the cooler still wins on this sum. Your water price is on your bill. This article states none, because it varies by supplier and it changes.
At 25 litres an hour the margin is wide. At 75 it narrows to a few dollars a kilolitre. Find your unit’s litres per hour before trusting either row.
Price the water, or the sum is half done.
What the refrigerated side really draws
The 1,000 watt figure is the one to question. An air conditioner’s nameplate shows its maximum draw, and the unit does not sit there. CHOICE says a medium unit draws up to about 1 kilowatt, and around 500 watts while cycling.
Change the input and the answer moves. At 500 watts for the same 240 hours, the air conditioner uses 120 kilowatt hours and costs $50.29 on the South Australian cap. The evaporative cooler at $35.20 now saves $15.09. That is 30 per cent, not 65. Same machines, same tariff. This is why the calculator asks for average watts while running, not the full-load figure.
The Energy Rating label is the better source. It shows annual electricity use in kWh for the Hot, Average and Cold bands, and its factsheet says to multiply that by your tariff to estimate running costs. Read the band for your climate.
The evaporative side has gaps of its own. CHOICE says some units draw 2 kilowatts or more, and Your Home says many have inefficient or large fans. Ducted units with inverter fans use much less power, according to energy.gov.au. Read the plate for the fan speed you actually run.
The plate is a ceiling. Use the average.
What the sum leaves out
The sum is energy only. It leaves out the daily supply charge, which applies whether either machine runs. It leaves out time-of-use tariffs, which can charge a different rate in the late afternoon, when cooling runs hardest. It leaves out solar. SolarQuotes says that for a home with a sufficiently sized solar system a reverse cycle air conditioner is likely the better choice.
It leaves out the machines themselves. RACV’s guide of 19 November 2024 lists evaporative units at $2,500 to $6,000, with ducted installation from $2,300 to $5,000 or more. Split systems run $500 to $2,000 or more, with installation averaging $600 to $800. Those are different systems, so compare quotes for your own house, not these rows. SolarQuotes puts an annual service at $250 to $350.
A view that turns up in online discussion is that pads, pumps and water eat into the saving. The guides back part of it. Water is priced above, and a yearly service is a real line on the ledger. Neither sits in the electricity lines, so those results are the best case, not the full bill.
Then there is winter. Your Home says built-in evaporative units can raise heating bills, through the ducts. Our guide to draught-proofing and where your heat escapes covers what to seal and what not to.
Your Home also names a ceiling fan as the first choice, ahead of either machine. No typical bill is given here. There is no honest one.
Count the watts, then check the air
Dry inland air and a dry heatwave: choose evaporative, and run the sum on your own watts to see the saving. A humid coast: choose refrigerated air. A cooler that cannot cool is the dearest option. Where both kinds of day turn up, keep the fan-only setting for the humid ones.
Reverse cycle has a fair claim too. It heats and it handles humidity, and SolarQuotes rates it the likelier better choice for a home with enough solar. That is a different sum, and the calculator above does not run it.
Before buying or switching, run the calculator twice: once with the wattage you expect, once with the wattage you fear. If the answer survives both, the saving is real.
Skip ratios from a brochure. Skip a portable unit in a sealed room. Count the watts, check the air, price the water.
Sources: Heating and cooling, Your Home, Australian Government (https://www.yourhome.gov.au/energy/heating-and-cooling); Heating and cooling, energy.gov.au (https://www.energy.gov.au/households/heating-and-cooling); How to be waterwise: evaporative coolers, Queensland Department of Local Government, Water and Volunteers (https://www.dlgwv.qld.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0005/1407560/residential-evaporative-air-coolers.pdf); Default market offer prices 2026-27: final determination, Australian Energy Regulator (https://www.aer.gov.au/system/files/2026-05/AER%20-%20Final%20determination%20-%20Default%20market%20offer%202026%E2%80%9327.pdf); How to read the new energy rating label for air conditioners, Energy Rating (https://www.energyrating.gov.au/sites/default/files/2022-12/Factsheet%20How%20To%20Read%20The%20ZERL%20For%20Air%20Conditioners.pdf); Evaporative coolers vs air conditioners, CHOICE (https://www.choice.com.au/home-and-living/cooling/air-conditioners/articles/evaporative-cooler-vs-air-conditioner); Best air conditioner, RACV (https://www.racv.com.au/royalauto/living/at-home/best-air-conditioner.html); Evaporative cooling vs reverse cycle air conditioning, SolarQuotes (https://www.solarquotes.com.au/blog/air-conditioning-evaporative-rcac-mb/)
